Hi there! I downloaded the "SuperTux Extra" mod and it reminded me of the old days when I had SuperTux Milestone 1. I even discovered that there is somehow two bonus islands that I missed! Here are some things I liked about it in the old days.
1. Metal Jumpy and Black Mr. Bomb
2. The classic sidescrolling camera
3. The music - for some reason I seem to prefer the old ones to the Milestone 2 and up ones.
4. The sound effects - the "Eggselent" for the egg, the gargle for the fireflower, and the "Whoo!" when you defeat an enemy are hilarious!
5. The ice theme being throughout the game
6. The long IcyIsland
Do you have any more stories about nostalgia for old versions of SuperTux?