capricom45 {l Wrote}:I thought I was welcome here, but I was in fact wrong on so many levels.
I am not welcome here because I am annoying, and worthless.
GeekPenguinBR {l Wrote}:Here, you can't wait many comments and you know this very well. I try to comment when I can help, but I'm working HARD in my free time to finish my projects for STK and I had to stop my work to give you a response. So, maybe other users are busy, too. OzoneOne is making songs like he said; ctdabomb and anon are making tracks,samuncle making all sort of art, ArDanWol is always sharing his opinion. Some other members, are always trying to help. The rest, who never appear (some 1,000,000 users), are lazy to comment as always, no matter if is you or hiker the person who posted the topic.
0zone0ne {l Wrote}:I'm honestly speechless... I don't know how you got to that conclusion, but let me tell you: Somebody who is "annoying", "worthless" and a "nuisance" does not get four pages of discussion and feedback on their work.
XGhost {l Wrote}:I'm not quite sure what you was expecting. Contributing needs time, passion, care and patience. You can't just produce something, put it in here and wait until somebody thinks this would might be cool. This is not a place to just presenting your personal work and then figuring to include it in the game. -> You already know that.capricom45 {l Wrote}:I thought I was welcome here, but I was in fact wrong on so many levels.
I am not welcome here because I am annoying, and worthless.
What decided you to think something like that? Every second day you update your work. Give us some time (1 to 2 weeks at least) to actually looking through it, so we're able to consider us with it. How are we supposed to understand your concept? Is the STK team the only instance who is in charge to give you feedback? I'm sure there are many good musicians in your circle of acquaintances. Also keep in mind what GeekPenguin said: we are working too -> besides that, lot of countries have summer holidays at this time.
It's a pity to hear that you want to leave because of us -> the community (which is not really fair in my opinion). I wish you good luck in your future projects.
Cheers
I will continue to work on music, but no announcements will be made here.
GeekPenguinBR {l Wrote}:The rest, who never appear (some 1,000,000 users), are lazy to comment as always, no matter if is you or hiker the person who posted the topic.
Total members 3328
Akien {l Wrote}:Could we stop with this fight over how many lazy users are reading this forum and not providing you the Holy Grail feedback that you are waiting for? This is not a "let's get free feedback" forum, this is a forum to discuss the development of open source games. ...Some people will be interested in browsing quickly through everything, while not willing to listen to every mockup that gets posted in any forum from someone hungry for feedback.
Akien {l Wrote}:Here are some numbers: Total members 3328
So we are quite far from one million users. So please stop doing all kinds of innuendos about the masses that read your threads and don't answer your desperate calls for feedback. There are very few people reading those forums, and even fewer who actually have time to contribute everywhere.
Akien {l Wrote}: I'm starting to wonder if I should just stop reading the STK forum at all, since it looks like my innocent silent browsing with a small contribution from time to time is not welcome. Really, stop whining about numbers and feedback.
ArDanWol {l Wrote}:Geez man. Everyone's welcome here. I dropped out of the conversation recently because you were at the point where you needed a professional musician to guide you. I am far from a musician and have little or no musical talent. I just give my opinions on tracks you post. Please don't give up on this.
GeekPenguinBR {l Wrote}:Just avoid using a topic created by a second person (in this case capricorn45) to adress a criticsm to a third person (in this case, myself). Don't take me as harsh, but sometimes, we need to clarify some things and I didn't like to be pictured as an imature guy hungry and desperate for feedback.
Well, I have no interest in becoming unsympathetic or start a virtual hostility with another person who is a fan of the same nice game.
capricom45 {l Wrote}:Thanks to feedback from Auria, I'm updating the track once again:
Google Drive: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B5a0TY ... sp=sharing
OneDrive: http://1drv.ms/1gACkic
changed: percussion track was removed (If you heard clicks in the song, that was the percussion track)
GunChleoc {l Wrote}:capricom45 {l Wrote}:Thanks to feedback from Auria, I'm updating the track once again:
Google Drive: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B5a0TY ... sp=sharing
OneDrive: http://1drv.ms/1gACkic
changed: percussion track was removed (If you heard clicks in the song, that was the percussion track)
The timing is a lot better than your first attempts when you joined this forum. You have improved a lot
Like others have posted, this needs a catchy melody on top of it.
Akien {l Wrote}:Sorry for overreacting. My rant was not specifically addressed at you (I just quoted your message as a basis for what triggered my annoyance), but more to the general atmosphere of the last few weeks regarding the giving of feedback.
I have absolutely no hostility against you, and please keep up with your nice contributions; I don't comment on them everytime, but I like the direction you're taking
GeekPenguinBR {l Wrote}:Create a good base with chords (played by keyboard), bass and drums according the STK stryle and, so, try to find a good melody to put "over".
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest